Introduction

Decentering Theater Histories: A Survey of Dramatic Practice Through the Ages

What does it mean to study “theatre history”? Many of us have been taught that history is a fixed point in the past—it is the story of what happened, when it happened, why it happened, and who was involved in its happening. The reality, though, is that studying history is a practice in the same way that making theatre is a practice. Both are acts of active creation.

Just as a script changes meaning depending on social context, production choices, casting, and more, what we know about the past is more often a product of a historian’s interest than it is about the what’s-and-where’s-and-who’s of the past. Of course, some of what we know about the past includes fixed information about dates and power players and new developments. The past itself doesn’t change.

At the same time, our information about the past is the product of research, and most people research what they’re interested in, and their questions are guided by their values and what they already believe. For example: if you are a historian interested in how the attitudes of royalty impacted theatre, you probably aren’t going to be doing a lot of research into how theaters were or were not cleaned. If you already believe that the Greeks invented plays, you’ll be looking for more information about how they did it. On the other hand, if you are interested in the ordinary labor of theatre, you’re probably going to be looking for information about who was responsible for sweeping, selling tickets, or washing clothes. If you are someone who is more interested in performance practices than scripted practices, you might be looking for evidence of oral traditions in African or Middle-Eastern cultures, and trying to figure out whether the Greek states had any interactions with them. In our daily lives, our creative practices, and intellectual endeavors, we all bring our own biases. Making those implicit biases explicit is part of the journey.

In this text, we’ve tried to decenter our approach to theatre histories. This means that not only are we looking at a wide-range of global and historical practices, we are also exploring different ideas about what it means to study them. The three authors of this book—Coya Paz Brownrigg, Ali-Reza Mirsajadi, and Emilio Williams—all teach in The Theatre School at DePaul University, a theater conservatory where the ethos is learning by doing. Our students approach their studies through the lens of training, and our focus is on actively making theatre from the perspective of our respective disciplines. We have students studying sound design, directing, wigs and makeup, dramaturgy, comedy, production management, arts administration, acting, playwriting, intimacy coordination, and more. (At the time of publication, The Theatre School has 27 different majors, and students do a deep dive in their area of study.) Teaching theatre history in this context, then, is not a theoretical act. We are tasked with teaching theatre in ways that are usable to our students as they train to be theatremakers. Our focus as professors of theatre history is to make sure our students know how to use theatre in their work and, most importantly, that they know how to recognize when there is information about the past they need to find out in order to successfully work on a particular production. Throughout this text, we’ve tried to model thinking about theatre history in application to our work today.

We also decenter by refusing the most conventional approach to studying theatre history in the United States—the idea that there are a handful of Great Important Plays (the canon), all of which can trace their lineage back to the Ancient Greeks and then to Early Modern Europe and then to the development of realism in the late 1880s. (What we’ve just done here is called glossing. Obviously even this approach to theatre history is a little more complex than we make it out to be, but we’ve chosen to outline the most simple version in order to get to what we’re really interested in.) We believe that it is more important to focus on social contexts and theatrical form than any one Great Play, so in many cases we’ve chosen plays that are representative of a certain time and place but are not taught as often as others—especially if those plays are by women!

Rather than perpetuating a rigid set-in-stone canon, our goal is to expose our students to enough methodology, and hopefully a wide enough variety of ways to understand theatre, that the student will be able to start defining his, her, or their mentor texts— those they want to learn from or enter in conversation with, now or in their future careers. In a way, creating their own personal canon.

We are also curious about how contemporary artists and researchers approach using theatre history. And finally, we are interested in a global approach to theatre history. How were different cultures influencing each other? How did geography impact performance practices? What happens when we change the definition of theatre from a “a scripted play” to live storytelling in front of an audience—does our origin story change too? (Short answer: yes. Long answer: the rest of this book.)

Let’s dive into this idea

Theatre history has long relied on written texts to describe and define the trajectory of theatrical practice. We use play scripts and other pieces from the written archive to declare the origins of words, of ideas, of human interactions, and of relationships between practitioners. In the absence of written archives, historians have looked to artifacts—images and examples of tools, clothing, housewares, etc. These tangible objects connect us to the past and help us interpret what was happening long before our lifetimes. In many ways, archives and artifacts from the past are deeply precious—the likelihood of any one document or book or piece of pottery surviving wars, weather, human carelessness, mold, rodents, and more is slim.

At the same time, most human knowledge, particularly in the day-to-day, is not written down. Think of a song many people living in the United States know well – Happy Birthday to You (lyrics by sisters Patty and Mildred Hill, 1893). Though this song is well-documented on paper and in recordings, most people probably learned this song from other people singing it. It is a performed tradition—passed from person to person to person by singing it together. Similarly, though we live in a time when we can learn a lot on YouTube or TikTok, a lot of what we do in our ordinary lives is stuff we learned by mimicking other people. How did you learn to make a bed? To dance a particular dance? To ride a bike? To pronounce a word? Most likely, you learned it through physical modeling—an important way that humans transmit information to each other and pass on knowledge. The knowledge that lives on through everyday performance of actions is one of the main ways we preserve culture.

Diana Taylor describes the way we know about how performance works (or worked, in the case of the past) as a balance between study of the archive (artifacts, including written texts) and the repertoire (the information our bodies pass on through first-hand witnessing). She cautions that to look at theatre history is always to ask not just what we know, but how we know it. Who documented a practice? What did they omit? What did they add? What words did they have to describe something that was new to them? How do words contain our understanding? (As we will explore in Volume Two, translation is an art that can radically change meaning—a “correct” translation can still blur the original, shaping an idea into something that is more familiar in our language than it is in the translated one.)

Anthropologists believe that theatrical performance has existed in some form across the globe throughout much of recorded history. However, the manner in which this performance was created, embodied, and passed down has been extremely variable. Over the past three centuries, cultural imperialism (the idea that one culture is better than another) has implanted the fallacy that theatre is a distinctly European art form that was then introduced to the rest of the world, who have since adopted its practice. As a result, theatre histories often feature very little representation from the non-Western world prior to the 20th century, when playwrights and theatre artists from the Global South began following the European dramatic model to create and stage their own texts. Interestingly, European theatre artists over the past century have developed their own fascination with non-Western performance styles, allowing these practices to inform their work. For instance, Brecht’s Epic Theatre found inspiration from China’s Peking Opera, Antonin Artaud’s Theatre of Cruelty stemmed in part from his fascination with Indonesian and Cambodian dance, and Peter Brook was heavily influenced by Ancient Sanskrit drama.

To this day, most global theatre history texts feature an abundance of information on European theatre but very little representation from the rest of the world. This is even the case in Oscar Brockett and Franklin Hildy’s tenth and most recent edition of History of Theatre, which is commonly treated as the quintessential and authoritative textbook on the subject. The following chart illustrates the amount of content that is devoted to various regions and time periods in that text, ranging from 353 pages on European Theatre from the Middle Ages onward to 2 pages on Middle Eastern Theatre:

 

A bar chart showing the number of pages devoted to different regions in History of the Theatre, 10th edition. Europe from the Middle Ages On has by far the most pages (about 350), followed by the U.S./Canada/Australia (about 80). All other regions range roughly from 2 to 35 pages.

Although scholars working on theatre from the non-Western world have labored to fill in these historical gaps, this is a slow process that necessitates collaboration on the part of translators, archivists, native artists and historians, and recognition from the wider field of scholars. This is further exacerbated by the dearth of extant (surviving) dramatic texts from the Global South. Starting during the European Renaissance, with the rediscovery of scripted playtexts from Ancient Greece and Rome, theatre’s resurgence in the region took a logocentric form. Plays would be written down in advance of production, and many of these texts were then preserved. Thanks to the invention of the printing press in the 15th century, copies of playtexts were now able to be published and disseminated. In 1623, only six years after Shakespeare’s death, 36 of his plays were collected and edited into what modern scholars call “The First Folio,” which popularized the treatment of contemporary playtexts as a form of dramatic literature which can be read, as opposed to simply seen in performance. Although this practice spread quickly throughout Europe, non-Western theatre practitioners were primarily introduced to plays-as-dramatic-literature via colonialism, and therefore, it is rare to find an existing playtext from outside Europe that was written before the 19th century.

Unfortunately, there are ways that our own volume replicates a disproportionate focus on the European Renaissance. We’ve included a broader array of plays and performance practices from around the world, though we still have a significant number of Greek, Roman, and Early Modern European plays. At the same time, in looking at these periods and places, we’ve focused on different questions than are often asked about the plays. We explore how queer and immigrant theatremakers have used the Ancient Greek plays to stake a contemporary claim in theatre. We pull in female writers who were significant in their time, but not quite as famous as some of their male peers. And we ask how theater was being used to reflect and comment on European colonialism. This textbook is the start of something we hope we will be able to continue to develop. In particular, we recognize that we are missing a deep dive into the diverse Asian practices that were happening in the 1500-1800’s. In part, this is a result of our own differing expertise. Maybe our approach to asking different questions about history will inspire you to do your own research into historical gaps?

Speaking of Approaches

This text is divided into three volumes, each of which is authored by a different one of us. We followed the format used to teach theatre history in The Theatre School, which is via a class called History of Dramatic Literature. History of Dramatic Literature (or HDL for short) is a year-long sequence across three quarters. Quarter one focuses on ancient theater practices and typically stops somewhere in the 1300s CE (Common Era). The second quarter focuses roughly on the 1500-1850s. And the final quarter starts in the late 1800s and ends up sometime close to our contemporary moment. That’s also how we’ve divided this book.

Each of these volumes is shaped by the time period we’re exploring, and our individual interests and expertise as theatre professors. Because of this, we think it is helpful to tell you a bit about who each of us are, and how we approach teaching theatre history.

Emilio Williams, author of Part 1

A headshot of Emilio.I believe the traditional canon is like one of those boyfriends who would text you in the middle of the night. That canonical tradition seems to be unavoidable, no matter what you do. In my approach to early theatre histories, I would like my students to think about what they would take and what they would leave behind from those traditional texts and practices. I am very interested in how subsequent theatre artists have reinvented and reimagined the stories of antiquity, particularly those who have honored them while subverting them, too. As a queer guy of a certain age, I’m also interested in performance in everyday life. I want to think about performance not as something that only occurs in a traditional, ritualized setting, but something we all practice, all the time.

My goal is to figure out a way to look at old plays not as artifacts but as sources of inspiration to develop new things in writing, on the stage, and in our daily lives. I must confess, I have a very long way to go in terms of understanding the gaps in my own knowledge. From that humble point of view, I want to promote curiosity within myself and those around me to become lifelong learners and researchers. In my early formative years, nothing was taught to me of the theatre histories that took place between the Roman and Everyman. I was never taught about the rich traditions of Asia, such as Sanskrit Theater, Japanese Noh, or the Chinese Zaju musicals. My main theatre practice is playwriting, and in that sense, I’m also particularly interested in what I can learn from the different styles of dramaturgy across times and places.

Coya Paz Brownrigg, author of Part 2

A headshot of Coya.I am primarily a director with a particular focus on community-engaged and co-created practice. I have a PhD in Performance Studies – this is a field of study that focuses more on the context around a performance than it does on the text itself, and performance studies scholars also think about performance more broadly than what happens in a theater. I also grew up in South America because my parents are anthropologists, and my personal research is split between ghost stories and arts economies in Chicago. I am a queer femme white woman whose first language is Spanish, a mom, a feminist, and a historiographer (you’ll hear more about that later) who is passionate about racial and economic equity. What does that mean for you as you’re reading Volume Two? It means that, whenever possible, I have tried to amplify texts by women and texts that explore racial and economic politics in the Americas. I also focus on the act of making history—it is very hard for me to state something as a definitive when there is any dispute at all about whether it is true, so I tend to offer different perspectives and list possibilities more than I stake a sure claim. This approach can be frustrating for people who want information to be cut and dry, but the reality is that history, like all things made by humans, is always a little messy.

Reza Mirsajadi, author of Part 3

A headshot of Reza.Like Coya, my artistic practice usually takes the form of directing, and I have a particular interest in the ways directing practice and theatrical aesthetics have developed alongside one another since the late-19th century. I have a PhD in Theatre and Performance Studies, and while my research expertise typically centers theatrical cultures and practice from the SWANA region (Southwest Asia and North Africa), I have a particular interest in the relationship between minoritarian performance strategies and systems and structures of power. With that in mind, my section of the textbook pays special attention to the ways hegemony works across multiple valences of identity, navigating the impact of colonialism, white supremacy, misogyny, heterosexism, Islamophobia, transphobia, ableism, and genocide on the theatre and vice versa. My volume is divided into three sections: European Modernism, Theatre of the Global Majority, and Identity-Based Theatre in the U.S. and Beyond.